Tag Archives: education

Interview with Elizabeth McDonald

I’ve known Elizabeth since middle school and we hung out in the same circles in high school. We’ve both become very different people since then but I believe we have some similarities in the paths we have followed. I called her while she was at the airport in Orlando, Florida, waiting for her flight home from a residency for the university for which she works (Walden).

 

What is it that you are doing for work?

I teach online, is the short answer. I teach mental health counseling, so the majority of my time is spent sitting in front of a computer. I’m fortunate enough that the organization I work for has requirements for residency and they are one-week intensive, so I get to go to those and teach.

Why do you have to go to them?

Everyone I’m teaching is a graduate student and they’re all going to become counselors. Clearly, a big part of becoming a counselor is that you have to have social skills. There are things they do online. I talk with the students every week for an hour and a half. Part of the residency – before they get to that stage – is that they have to go through these experiences for us to do some gate keeping. They have two residencies that are six days each. So essentially it’s twelve days of gate keeping so that we can make sure that we can vouch for everyone who is going through our program.

Do you feel comfortable with teaching like that?

I do. It’s funny because I didn’t want to. I looked at it as a sacrifice and a second choice. I didn’t think there was any possible way to do it. But now I’m completely sold on it. I’ve done this for a little over a year now. Frankly, the gate keeping that happens through my institution is a lot stronger than any of the land-based institution than I ever experienced or was a part of. I’m blown away.

Do you think that going online is the future of education?

Without a doubt. I don’t even think it’s the future, I think it’s the present.

You think the education they’re getting is just as good?

Absolutely. I think there are always some aberrations but that’s everywhere. In my program, I’m evaluated every other month so I have to maintain a high quality of education. I’ve never heard of anyone who is evaluated every other month. We all have PhDs, so it’s not like we’re all slackers. But it’s not in an offensive or obtrusive way, but to ensure that I’m giving something to my students every week.

Do you meet some of your students at the residencies?

Yes, I do. I like meeting them at residencies and that’s for a couple reasons. I recently learned that I’m a “hard instructor.” I didn’t know this. It turns out that everyone thinks I’m a hardass, but what it really is, is that I want everyone to write well. I teach classes at the beginning and the end of the program. But in the beginning I really press forward to make sure that all the students I work with leave with the ability to write well. It sounds silly with a masters program but one of the benefits of the masters program is that we get students from all walks of life – the vast majority of students are much older than me, actually. A lot of them are returning to school and may have lost some of the writing skills they had before. So it’s nice to meet people at residencies and show them that I’m a real person.

It also turns out I’m a computer bitch.

What does that mean?

Well, at residency they tell all the students to put their computers down and listen to the speaker. Because there are so many students nowadays it’s hard to determine who is looking at a PowerPoint and who is on Facebook. So it’s ironic that we’re an online institution but when they’re at residency they don’t use their computers hardly at all.

But you’re pretty militant about it?

Apparently.

What’s a typical day like for you?

I am pretty militant in that. I know that because I teach online that it would be easy to keep weird hours. I get up at seven o’clock every morning and I sit down in front of my computer by eight-thirty or nine at the latest. I post at discussion boards, I grade papers and do track changes in them. I may have a phone call or two with a student who is struggling and needs to touch base with me and let them know that there is someone on the other end of the computer. Every week I have a one and a half hour teleconference with twelve students. Also, I may have a phone call with another faculty member. But at five o’clock I’m done. It’s one of those amazing things that doesn’t happen much in academia. I don’t ever work on weekends except for residencies.

So the school pays for your airfare to the residencies and all that?

Yeah. It’s awesome. I make a phone call or send an email and tell them where I am flying out of and where the residency is and it’s all taken care of in about five minutes. I don’t have to book the flight or set up the hotel or anything. The only thing I have to do is pay for my food while I’m there and then they reimburse me for that.

When we were in high school, is this what you pictured doing with your life?

Oh, god no. I had a couple visions for my life. One was that I was going to have my own restaurant. I wanted to go to culinary school before anyone knew what it was. Then I got into high school and fell into that whole ultra alternative evangelical thing – I don’t know what to call it because it was a very strange scene. It was a very unique evangelical community. When that happened I thought, “Well, maybe I could cater and be a pastor’s wife.” I really did have this desire to be taken care of, I think. I think more than a PhD or whatever, I just want to bring my own fulfillment into my life, which is very different than I could have imagined in high school.

What do you mean by your own fulfillment?

At the end of the day if I’m not answering to my partner or my parents, and I’m only answering to myself, I want to feel okay. Rather than wanting to check in with other people and see that I’m okay with what I’m doing with my life.

I think that so much of who I was when you and I knew each other was me looking externally not just socially but also spiritually. Or “I’m doing the right thing, so I’m okay.” So much of my life was consumed with making sure that others viewed me as being okay. I believe at the end of the day I’m proud of who I am and what I’ve accomplished and who the fuck else cares?

Where you live right now in Ohio, does it remind you of living in Goshen (Indiana, where we grew up)?

Yeah, it’s horrible. It’s half the size of Goshen. So if you would address a letter to Heather and me as the two lesbians in Wooster, it would get to me. That’s kind of our ongoing joke. I really fought it professionally because living in Ohio I have to go back and take classes and take the big counseling exam and get re-certified even though I’m currently certified. I threw a fit – a yearlong fit actually, for having to get re-certified. And also living in a small, Midwestern, Mennonite community. I think that like Goshen, there’s something weird about the Midwest. I think that wherever I am in the Midwest there are always a few freaks in the community and I tend to really be connected to them.

What kinds of freaks are there in Wooster?

Now I feel badly. I don’t really mean that they’re true freaks. I’ve found a connection with some of the Unitarian Universalists in the community. It’s funny because I really didn’t want to go to church and Heather’s an atheist. But we didn’t know how to meet people – quite literally. So we decided to go to the Unitarian church hoping for at least some intellectual banter. We are thrilled with the community we found there. We don’t go as often – not like when I was a Christian. I don’t feel like I have to go. But we’ve met quite a number of people who get along with me in terms of my socio-political view. I don’t know – maybe Democrats would be considered freaks in the definition I am providing here.

You may have told this before but what was it like coming out to your parents?

My dad guessed it. That was not a problem at all. For my mom it was a lot more difficult. She still struggles. She’s not a mean person, but she yelled at me. That was her first reaction – to yell at me and tell me it was not normal. Even though she’s not spiritual or religious at all. I haven’t figured out where that comes from. Heather came home for the first time for Thanksgiving last year. We’d been together for two and a half years when she first came home to meet my mom officially. My mom is standoffish and she never asks about Heather. She’ll be nice to her but coming out sucks, no matter who it’s to.

Was your dad okay with everything?

Oh yeah.

I know the easy answer to this, but if you wouldn’t mind digging a little bit – what’s something you used to believe in that you don’t believe in anymore?

Elizabeth followed up with me on this question, as she wasn’t satisfied with her original answer.

1) Research. All research is tainted. As a creator of the teeniest tiniest bit of research and “knowledge” I now know that all statistics are essentially bullshit. Most “knowledge” is based on statistics. And the alternative to research is often even worse than research itself. I don’t believe in “facts” without methodology and limitations. That kind of limits what I believe in general.

2) Education for the sake of education. I no longer believe in formal education for the sake of education. I think this is a luxury that we, as a society, have adapted, and it is a luxury that we can no longer afford. I can’t tell you the number of students that I talk to who want PhDs. When I ask them why, they can’t answer. This is upsetting to me. Why does our society want to be more educated through formal education? Why is academia so valued? Don’t get me wrong – I like formal education. I have a PhD for god’s sake. The problem that I have is when students who don’t have the money to spend begin to rack up debt to take classes in a profession that they don’t know anything about. I think that common sense and grounding is lost in our society and that we have needs far greater than more people with degrees. Education is best learned outside of academe.

What’s your biggest fault?

My biggest fault is over-investment.

How so?

I’m a relatively passionate person. I can get excited about things really easily and I don’t always know when to stop. I think that applies to my professional life. I know that my colleagues can spend half as much time as I do on their classes, but it takes its toll on me. I think that’s true of my education. I think that’s true of food. I think that’s true of a lot of things in my life.

Have you found ways to combat that?

I think asking others and inviting them into my life to help me keep perspective is important. I lose perspective pretty quickly.

Me too. That’s a good life lesson: have other people give you perspective.

Yeah. If you’ve got a pill for that I’d like it.

No, it’s just a constant reminder to reach out to people. And it’s also a good reason to have a therapist.


Interview with Julie

Julie and I met through couchsurfing but discovered we have a great deal in common, including our senses of humor and interest in the interweb as an academic subject. Julie is one of my favorite people with whom to have discussions, as they are both hilarious and rewarding. When I am fortunate enough to spend time with Julie my motto has been “non-stop party wagon” and thanks to that we’ve had some crazy fun experiences together.

What’s something you used to believe in that you don’t believe in anymore?

Well, obviously God.

That’s too easy but I’ll bite: you used to believe in God?

Yeah. I was terrified. I know why it got to be so scary. It’s because they had these things in the Catholic Church they used to give out to children to implant that seed of fear. They gave us glow-in-the-dark rosaries. Ostensibly children were supposed to stay up all night and pray for their infant sins. What kind of sins did I have when I was little? None. But now I don’t do that anymore.

Really? You don’t commit sins anymore? Is that what you’re saying?

I do, I just don’t pray for them.

Agnostic or atheist?

Atheist. I’m 100% sure in my mind.

What classes are you teaching this fall at your college?

I’m teaching the freshmen English that everyone has to take. I’m also taking a remedial one for adult learners that have to take it to get into freshman English. Then I’m teaching a second semester freshman English. So I’ve got lots of freshman. I’m indoctrinating them early.

With what kind of stuff?

I don’t have too much leeway with what I can teach. The school makes their own textbook edited by professors at the university.

Why do they do that?

I don’t know. I think it’s partially so that there’s unity in the course work but I think it’s also about the money they get from it. A lot of places do it.

What’s your favorite thing about Savannah?

I think it’s the aesthetics. It’s the juxtaposition of the old, Spanish moss and the old architecture and the freaks walking around.

The freaks?

SCAD (Savannah College of Art and Design) students.

Ah, okay. What’s your least favorite thing?

Not being able to walk around at night. I don’t like that.

You don’t think that’s the case anywhere?

I think everywhere. I think my neighborhood is the safest place but it’s still not. I lived in New York City and never felt scared to walk around anywhere at night. It’s like Disneyworld there now.

What’s one of your favorite memories from living in NYC?

Memories of New York were really about some of the routines we got into. My friend Kate and I went to Snacky every week. Every Wednesday night we went to this little hole in the wall in Brooklyn and drank shots of cheap Saki. For some reason it was this huge event every week. It was sort of our own Brooklyn version of taco night.

I don’t know what that is.

It’s when suburban people who are married – that’s the only thing they have to look forward to.

Julie as a kid – her self-proclaimed “apex of coolness”

So, you grew up in suburbia – what caused you to dislike it?

I just sensed it was bland. Knowing it was diluted. It felt cultureless. I knew there was more out there than going to swim practice and taco night.

Yeah, there was Wednesday night at Snacky!

Oh my god, it’s all so circular!

But you didn’t end up hating Georgia over it?

No. I never had anything against the South per se. I like it here. I was surprised when I went to NYC and went to Columbia and it was supposed to be this liberal institution and everything was supposed to be with social justice as the end goal. But it was okay to make fun of Southerners and talk shit about rednecks and it was blatant. I felt a lot of prejudice from my professors about being from Georgia. It renewed my sense of pride, though. For a while I tried to hide my accent, though, which is a weird mixture of North and South because of my parents being from the North but growing up in the South. The last semester I was there I was trying to be the biggest ‘neck ever.

But that’s not who you are, though, is it?

Somewhat.

How so?

I feel like I’m a Southern girl. I love the culture and the food and the centeredness on family. Maybe it’s not distinctly Southern. I don’t know.

Do you see that changing, though? Have you seen that culture being diluted or is the stereotypical Southern culture still there?

It’s different for me because I grew up around Atlanta and most people that live in Atlanta aren’t from there. People say Atlanta isn’t the South. But then I moved down this way and have lived here for seven or eight years in all including living and teaching in a really rural area. In different places it felt more Southern like when the kids were making sure my car was in running order and inviting me to go to the “mud bog.”

What’s that?

Well, it wasn’t even in that town. They had to go to the next town over to the famed “mud bog.” It’s basically a muddy hole and people drive their cars through it. And then if you come to school on Monday with lots of mud caked on your car you’re pretty awesome.

How did this become their thing to do?

I think it’s a way to show off the vehicles. They all had huge trucks with giant tires. And there’s nothing else to do. What are they going to do?

Drink and smoke pot.

Oh, they did that. With my colleagues at the school.

For real?

Oh yeah.

How’d you feel about that?

I thought it was dangerous territory and not at all desirable. But it’s not taboo there.

It’s something they’ve been doing there for years?

Yeah.

So what was it like coming from a situation where you were at an elite Ivy League school like Columbia and then returning to Georgia? Was there a sense of discrimination because you had lived in NYC and left the South?

Not really because I moved back. People asked me why I moved back and when you say you want to be closer to your family and people you care about that feels comfortable to everybody. My boyfriend’s dad was like, “How’d you like living in that big ol’ city?” I told him I was a teacher in Harlem for two years and he couldn’t believe it.

How was it teaching in Harlem?

That was fun. I didn’t have a boss so I could do whatever I want.

Why didn’t you have a boss? What kind of school was this?!

It was a GED program for adults. It was inside one of the public elementary schools there in Harlem. Everybody that lived in that particular neighborhood was from the West Indies so we had a language barrier. I was teaching math, which was laughable because I still can’t calculate a tip. I was literally teaching myself the morning before the lesson what I was going to teach that day. But their scores improved so I guess it worked. But everyone that knew me thought it was pretty outrageous.

Harlem was one of the only places that felt like home because I’d walk to work. I lived in Morningside Heights and would walk to work and people would say hi and greet me and that never happened anywhere else in the city.

Has your sense of style always been what it is or was it influenced by living in NYC? I’ve always liked your fashion sense and hairstyle.

I’ve always dressed abnormally. Maybe just the fact that people in NYC are more willing to take risks and they don’t care. When you live in suburbia they look at you funny if you’re not blending in. I used to be a seamstress and made everything I wore.

In high school?

College. When I became a vegan I decided I was going to be so anti-corporate I was going to sew my own clothes, so fuck you Gap!

Where did the anti-corporate thing come from?

Just getting out of my parents’ house and having more freedom to question some things that may have been at odds with their values and lifestyles.

But a lot of people come out of that and don’t question things.

I don’t know where it comes from. I think it was probably somewhat stemming from an obsession with the Beats and hippie culture.

Did you have friends in high school who were into stuff like that?

Yeah. In high school they had this thing called Marietta Independent Learning Environment (MILE) and they took us out of all our normal classes. There were ten of us who had our classes together and we would become obsessed about the same things together. I remember Vonnegut and Kerouac being passed around. We were allowed to create our own curriculum. So it started with that. We were really into talking about art that wasn’t really in the mainstream high school curriculum.

How did you get chosen for this class?

It was weird. Your teacher would pinpoint you and then you’d have to take this test and it was supposed to test your creativity. I guess I passed it. It’s funny because we’re all still best friends to this day.

It sounds like it changed you in a lot of ways.

I think so. That was my first year being educated outside Catholic school, too. Finding people outside of a class of thirty people.

So the ten of you would have really stood out amongst others?

Yeah, I think so. We were the freaks.

So all that is where the fashion sense comes into play? Exploring your personality through clothing?

Yeah.

And you were that way in college, too?

Yeah, definitely. It was a different sort of thing: long, flowy skirts.

Grateful Dead t-shirts?

Well, I still listen to the Dead to this day but I don’t think I ever owned a shirt. No tie-dye. That was offensive to me even back then.

Do you think you’d get along with 19-year-old Julie?

I think she’d think I was too serious now. I was a lot more – I don’t know if ethereal is the right word, but I feel like I existed a lot more in the clouds back then. I didn’t have any direction. I knew what I liked and didn’t like and wanted to have fun.

So what caused you to find the direction to go into education?

Well, I did always know that I was going to do that. I just thought that anybody could be a teacher and I didn’t have to work that hard if I took that path which turned out to be true in some sense. The further I went along the more serious I got about it. But back then you didn’t have to try very hard to take that route, unfortunately.

But how did it go from there to wanting to pursue the PhD and wanting to teach teachers?

I just realized I was good at it and I was better at it than a lot of my colleagues. [laughs] I wanted to make it worthwhile for kids to be sitting in there. I saw a lot of damage done by poor teachers, especially when you’re teaching writers and you’re squashing them with ideas like the five paragraph essay. No one wants to write anymore or they think they’re a bad writer because they can’t produce this highly structured, arbitrarily composed thing. But the doctorate, in particular, was because I saw how outdated the curriculum was and every time I tried to do anything with new media literacy, bringing in technology or visual literacy – then I’d meet a lot of resistance with the administration. There is all this fear around safety issues.

Do you think you have more freedom at the university level than you did at the high school level?

Oh yeah. I can do pretty much whatever I want. Part of that freedom is being able to justify whatever it is I do.

You can show them studies and information that backs up how and what you’re teaching.

Yeah.

Especially now that people have done the research. It’s not like the Internet is a year old.

At my old high school I was wanting to publish students’ work online and have them do podcasts and they just wanted to have it be within the school and put it on the intranet. And I told them to just forget it.

How come you didn’t want to do that?

I’d do that but it’s ridiculous that people didn’t even want to listen to what the benefits of having that wider audience would have been.

Getting people to learn from other people’s experiences.

Yeah, and kids are highly motivated by having an audience outside their own classroom. A lot of what we do is pseudo-transactional. It’s supposed to have an audience but it doesn’t really. They know it’s just the teacher reading it and then it goes in the recycling bin after they get a grade. There’s no motivation to do anything there.

Do you feel like that’s changing?

Yeah, I do. Just with some of the professional development I’ve been doing with the writing project and working with teachers – I do a lot of the technology and new media professional development and tons of teachers are showing up for this stuff on Saturdays on their own time. From what they tell me they have the hardware, software and wiring now to do it. It used to be that you’d have to get a grant out of your own pocket to get this stuff. Now it’s a given. I think the assumption now is that if your school doesn’t have this stuff it’s deficient.

Julie and some random guy


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.